Slate's Bizbox
explainer: Answers to your questions about the news.

Is a $10 Bag of Ice Illegal?When it's price gouging, and when it's just really expensive.

By Brendan I. Koerner
Posted Wednesday, Aug. 18, 2004, at 5:40 PM ET

Hurricane Charley has reportedly brought out the worst in some merchants, as the Florida attorney general's office has been inundated with complaints about price gouging. Among the travesties cited are a $10 bag of ice in Orlando, $3 gallons of gas, and $2,000 power generators. At what point does a little legal—albeit morally suspect—profiteering turn into illegal price gouging?

In Florida, as in at least 20 other states with similar laws on the books, pricing curbs kick in during declared emergencies—say, when thousands of residents have been walloped by a natural disaster. The standards vary from state to state, but the rule of thumb is that gouging occurs when a good or service—especially those deemed essential, such as fuel or food—costs at least 10 percent to 25 percent more than the norm prior to the emergency.

Not every state's price-gouging law details how much of an increase will make a markup illegal. The Florida law, which was passed in 1992 in response to massive gouging in the wake of Hurricane Andrew, forbids vendors from charging an "unconscionable price" for their wares during an emergency. The attorney general is responsible for deciding what constitutes an unconscionable price, using prices over 30 days prior to the crisis as a barometer of what's fair market value.

Other states give their attorneys general less discretion. In Arkansas, for example, the law caps price increases during an emergency at 10 percent of the pre-emergency price. The cap remains in place for 30 days after the disaster hits and can be extended by another 30 days if local officials see fit. But if a merchant can prove that the emergency caused their costs to rise so much as to make a 10 percent increase a money-losing proposition, they can instead charge 10 percent above the wholesale cost plus whatever the pre-emergency markup was.

In some states, a governor can also institute temporary price-gouging controls with an executive order, even if a state hasn't been directly hit with a calamity. The day after the terrorist attacks of 2001, for example, South Carolina Gov. Jim Hodges signed a 15-day executive order to prevent price gouging on gas, despite the fact that his state was hundreds of miles from the violence. (Hodges was concerned that oil companies would raise their prices in the wake of the attacks, and that gas-station owners would in turn use that as an excuse to gouge customers.)

Not every price-gouging law requires an emergency to take effect. In New York, when it comes to milk, supermarkets are forbidden from charging any more than 200 percent above what the farmer sold it for originally. Last month, New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer announced that an investigation had revealed that 30 percent of stores were gouging consumers on milk.

Next question?

Explainer thanks Justin Marks of the National Conference of State Legislatures.

Print This ArticlePRINTDiscuss this in The FrayDISCUSSEmail to a FriendE-MAIL
Share on FacebookPost to MySpace!Share with MixxDigg ThisShare with RedditShare with del.icio.usShare with FurlShare with Ma.gnolia.comShare with SphereShare with Stumble Upon
Brendan I. Koerner is a contributing editor at Wired and a columnist for Gizmodo. His first book, Now the Hell Will Start, is out now.
Photograph of ice on Slate's home page © Paul Edmondson/Corbis.
Join the Fray: our reader discussion forum
What did you think of this article?
POST A MESSAGE | READ MESSAGES

Remarks from the Fray:

In the states that preserve the original markup on the new wholesale price, a sensible choice is being made. After all, the worst thing to have happen is ... no sale at all. If the costs have risen such that it no longer is sensible to retail a good at 10% higher than the prior market value... not difficult to have happen if the transport systems have broken down and a more expensive option is required... then the store will just stop selling whatever good it is.

However, if the cap is flexible with regard to underlying costs, then gouging is still prevented.

Anyway, its nice to see that some states have foreseen this.

--BenK

(To reply, click here)


Can anyone please tell me what "price gouging" is, and how it is anything more than supply and demand in action?

Don't use words such as "unfair" without explaining exactly what you mean, and why it is any of the government's business to insure that private interactions are "fair" in the first place.

--Chad-B

(To reply, click here)

(8/18)

Washington Post